December 05, 2012
What is Christian Freedom?
Engaging with Calvin in his “Institutes” is a task that, while initially daunting, is of tremendous value. Reflecting upon his chapter on Christian Freedom, this essay begins with a brief review of the cultural context within which Calvin worked. Following this, a remark on the structure of the chapter will be presented along with some observations on various features of his argument and use of scripture within.
Calvin’s Cultural Context
As a second generation reformer, Calvin was dedicated to acquainting people with a correct understanding of the gospel. His cultural context was one where the church still wielded great power over individuals. The mantra of “go well or go to hell” is a fitting summary of the message that Calvin (like other reformers) sought to destroy. People rightly feared the reality of hell. According to the Catholic Church, however, the only option to avoid hell was to comply with the rules and traditions set forth by the church. Consequently, the devout Christian was burdened by a perpetual sense of guilt, a burden that held no assurance of salvation. That Christians could be lead to this mindset was an abhorrent heresy to Calvin, and so he sought to bring a correct scriptural understanding to the minds of believers.
Understanding this cultural climate provides the context not only for understanding Calvin’s motivation for including this chapter, but also for building an appreciation for the power and method of his argument.
The Structure of the Argument
The placement of this chapter within Calvin’s work is significant. “We must now”, he states, “discuss Christian freedom”. In previous chapters, Calvin has provided a robust and compelling defence of the doctrine of justification by faith. It is only on the back of this teaching that a person can truly understand what it means to be free as a Christian. Conversely, however, unless Christian freedom is rightly understood, then the doctrine of justification by faith loses much of its potency. “But freedom is such an appendage of justification and is of no little avail in understanding its power”. For Calvin, the doctrines of justification by faith and Christian freedom are inextricably linked.
Nevertheless, the distinction between the two is important. For Calvin, the doctrine of Christian freedom is concerned with how a Christian is to live their life in their justified state. This chapter then is less about the process by which a person is set free and is more about how a person is permitted to live now that they are free.
There is a centrifugal progression in Calvin’s argument. Starting with Christ’s work at the centre (sections 2-3), Calvin moves through to explain the effects of this work for the individual (sections 4-9), and then onto the implications this has on the way an individual relates to other believers (sections 10-13). Finally Calvin explains how a Christian is to understand their freedom within the bounds of civil government (section 14-16). This “Christ – Self – Church – Community” pattern reveals the genius in Calvin’s ability to weave doctrine and life together in a compelling and powerful way.
Features of the Argument
Beyond its structure, certain features of Calvin’s argument are worth noting. The first feature is the passion that is infused in his writing. He despises those leaders who (in the name of Christ) maintain the yoke of slavery over those under their care. He yearns for believers to understand the freedom they have in Christ, not so they live licentiously or carelessly, but so they, through faith, can in good conscience experience the riches of living exempt from God’s condemnation.
Here lies a second important feature of Calvin’s argument: his ability to anticipate and address the various arguments in opposition. Does Christian freedom promote sinful living? Does Christian freedom promote luxurious living? Is a Christian free to use his freedom at will, despite what it means for his brother or sister? Does Christian freedom lead to rebellious anti-state behaviour? Calvin anticipates each of these counter-arguments and responds with a Biblically supported and theologically sound answer.
The final feature to note is the way Calvin bases much of his argument on core Christian principles. The most prominent question raised by the topic of Christian freedom is “What is the right way to live as a Christian? How do I discern what is best?” (cf. Philippians 1:9). The response given by Calvin can be summarised by three guiding “laws”: the law of conscience (section 8), the law of contentment (section 9) and the law of love and edification for neighbour (section 12). For all the complexity of the topic at hand, Calvin is able to use core Christian principles to guide people in an appropriate application of their Christ-won freedom.
Use of Scripture
Calvin’s use of scripture is appropriate and insightful. There are some key passages from which he builds his argument. In relation to his point about Christians being freed from the law, he rightly claims that “the entire argument of the letter to the Galatians hinges upon this point”. In relation to Christians being emancipated from the power of sin he cites Romans 6. In expounding all of these passages, Calvin insists on drawing the reader back to the initial context of the Biblical literature, thus demonstrating his “Historical Grammatical” approach to interpreting the Bible.
Probably one of the most surprising aspects of Calvin’s argument is the absence of the Exodus. Nowadays, a Biblical Theology on freedom would undoubtedly include the Exodus as a key pattern for understanding God’s desire for those he has set free. One might argue that to Calvin’s mind this could have bordered on allegory, and so he may have been reticent to include it here. Another argument, however, might be that he simply did not need to include it given that sufficient Biblical material had already been given to adequately support his point. Certainly the presentation of his argument stands strong without the inclusion of the Exodus, but it is an interesting exclusion nonetheless.
Conclusion
Calvin was driven to present a right understanding of the gospel to people within his cultural context. His insights and approach to theology are enduring. In a time where the gospel continues to be mistaught, misunderstood and consequently misapplied, contemporary Christians can gain much from understanding his insights, his methods and his motivations for presenting God’s truths to the world.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment